Annotated Bibliography:
Stop and Frisk
Nicholas DiJennaro
English 201, Section 41
Professor Matyakubova
March 31, 2015
Police Practices on the Docket. (n.d.). Retrieved April 1, 2015, from http://www.acluohio.org/ cases/terry-v-ohio
Summary: A police officer noticed a man, John Terry talking to another man while walking up and down the street and peaking through a store window continuously. The officer than noticed that the two men then met up with another man. This led the officer to believe that the suspects were checking the store to be a possible robbery. The officer then proceeded to question the men but decided to frisk them first. As a product of the frisk John Terry was charged with carrying a concealed weapon. The issue presented in the Supreme Court was: whether a search for weapons without probable cause for an arrest is an unreasonable search under the Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution. The Court held in favor of the U.S.. Given the facts: the suspicious activity was a violent crime involving a concealed weapon, the men talking, walking up and down, and peaking through the store window repeatedly was reasonable enough for the officer to do a quick frisk.
Analysis: These facts are what gave the officer reasonable suspicion. Even if Terry would have had no concealed weapons his behavior led the officer to believe that criminal activity was afoot, aside from his previous experience. This source shapes my argument since the case proves that the officer was studying behavior under the circumstances and not trying to discriminate. This is a reliable source because it is a Supreme Court case.
Adams v. Williams | Casebriefs. (1972, June 12).
Summary: Adams, a police officer received a tip from an informant that Williams, was in possession of a gun while sitting in his car early in the morning. The Respondent rolled down the window and when he did so, the police officer reached in and removed a fully loaded gun from the Respondent’s waist. The gun was not in plain view but where the informant said it would be. A search was conducted shortly after, and heroin, a second handgun and a machete were found on the Respondent’s person and in the vehicle. The issue at hand here was whether an officer can base stop and frisk from information supplied by an informant. The Court reversed the judgment of the court of appeals.
Analysis: A stop and frisk can be based off information provided by a reliable informant. An officer can only look in a specific place if item in question is not in plain sight. This source shapes my argument in that an officer must only base his/her search on a specific place provided by a reliable informant. If the search produces illegal contraband, the officer may proceed to continue the search. This is a reliable source coming from the Supreme Court reasoning.
FindLaw | Cases and Codes. (1990, May 11).
Summary: The police received an anonymous tip that the defendant, White, would be leaving a particular apartment at a certain time in a particular vehicle. The defendant would be traveling to a particular motel and ultimately would be in possession of cocaine. The police proceeded to the apartment building and saw a matching vehicle as the caller described it, observed White and followed her to the motel. The police also did their own particular investigation. A consensual search of the vehicle revealed marijuana and after she was arrested, cocaine was found in her purse.
Analysis: The issue presented was whether an anonymous tip is reliable enough to provide reasonable suspicion to make an investigatory stop. In favor of Alabama, the Court held that alone, the tip lacks reliability but by looking at the totality of the circumstances, the police also did their independent work aside from the tip. If the tip is not reliable enough, police officers must do investigations of their own to verify if a search would be permissible. Not all tips lead to a legal search. This source shapes my argument because it shows the correct way to act when given an anonymous tip, I find that this is a reliable source.
Illinois v. Gates | Casebriefs. (1983, June 8).
Summary: On May 3, 1978, the Police Department of Bloomingdale, Illinois, received an anonymous letter that a couple was engaged in selling drugs. The wife drove their car to Florida on May 3 to be loaded with drugs, and the husband would fly down in a few days to drive the car back. The car’s trunk was loaded with drugs. Presently the respondents were supposed to have over $100,000 worth of drugs in their basement. Acting upon the tip the officer found out that in fact the husband made a reservation on May 5 flight back to Florida. Arrangements for the surveillance of the flight were made by the DEA. The video showed that the husband stayed in a motel room registered under the wife’s name and in the morning left in a car with a woman, with an Illinois license plate, heading to the Bloomingdale area. A search warrant of the automobile and residence was granted. Upon entering the home the officers found marijuana along with other contraband in their car as well. The Court held that an investigatory stop is valid if the reliability of the informant and, the quantity and quality of the information provided by the informant arouse reasonable suspicion, along with corroborated police findings. Analysis: Although the anonymous tip contained a lot of information, an officer must verify to make sure that such information is enough to act upon. A key of elements were must be taken into consideration, not merely a person’s race. This source shapes my argument as it proves that the actions taken by the police department in this case, were justified.
Hobson, J., & Young, R. (2014, February 25).
Summary: Shira Scheindlin, a U.S. District Court judge for the Southern District of New York, held that New York City's "stop and frisk" policy violates the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments. Stop and frisk is an NYPD policy where an officer may question a pedestrian if there is reasonable suspicion that a suspect committed, is committing, or will commit a felony or misdemeanor. A report was conducted which showed that stops lowered from 685,724 in 2011, to 532,911 in 2012.
Analysis: The majority stopped were black people followed by Hispanic people. The difference seen in how many stops are made in certain areas more than others is due to the racial makeup of a precinct as well as the crime rate. Research shows that only few of the many stops result in seizures. The definition to stop and frisk is not racial discrimination. After the case Floyd v. NYCPD, stops significantly reduced. This source shapes my argument into bringing about the real definition as well as a way to correct any misuse of the law. This source is reliable because it has statistically proven research by professors.
Center on Race, Crime and Justice. (2010, March 1). Stop, Question & Frisk Policing Practices In New York City: A Primer.
Summary: To ensure that a stop is supported by reasonable suspicion factors such as whether the informant was reliable; whether the tip received is valid; personal observation; and whether the place was a high crime area, must be observed. To ensure that a frisk is valid one must determine whether a police officer’s belief that the suspect was armed and dangerous was justified as it could pose a threat to his safety or the public’s, and whether the scope of the pat down was permissible. Stops have tripled from 20032009 in New York City. Research is needed to determine the individual/social cost as well as the public benefit of stops.
Analysis: The most common reason for stops has been due to furtive movements rather than engaging in a violent crime or carrying a suspicious object in plain sight. In order for a stop to be valid it must go through certain procedures. Improper stop and frisks must be declared unconstitutional but should be differentiated from those following legal protocol. This is a valid research conducted by the John Jay Center on Race department.
No comments:
Post a Comment